Skip to content

Saint Matthew School

Indianapolis, IN

Test scores
Indiana Department of Education · ILEARN

English language arts

223 students tested

62.8% at or above proficiency in 2025–26.

  • Above proficiency18
  • At proficiency122
  • Approaching proficiency77
  • Below proficiency6

Math

223 students tested

39.9% at or above proficiency in 2025–26.

  • Above proficiency19
  • At proficiency70
  • Approaching proficiency78
  • Below proficiency56

Science

72 students tested

56.9% at or above proficiency in 2025–26.

  • Above proficiency17
  • At proficiency24
  • Approaching proficiency28
  • Below proficiency3
Measure2023–242024–252025–26
Students tested697872
Proficient65.2%74.4%56.9%

Social studies (grade 5)

37 students tested

59.5% at or above proficiency in 2025–26.

  • Above proficiency2
  • At proficiency20
  • Approaching proficiency12
  • Below proficiency3

ELA, math, and social studies cannot be compared with years before 2025–26.

Attendance
Indiana Department of Education

7.1% of students were chronically absent in 2024–25.

Measure2022–232023–242024–25
Total student count368367378
Chronically absent6.5% · 249.0% · 337.1% · 27

Chronically absent means missing 10% or more of the school days a student was enrolled.

School Profile

Location

City, Large

Religious Affiliation

Catholic

Roman Catholic

Student Body

Coed

Enrollment

320 students

Student-Teacher Ratio

12:1

Principal

Cara Swinefurth

Demographics
Hispanic/Latino9.4%
x
White68.4%
x
Black or African American11.6%
x
Asian0.6%
x
Two or More Races9.1%
x
American Indian or Alaska Native0.6%
x
Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander0.3%
x
Tuition & Scholarships
Indiana scholarships accepted
Choice Scholarship

Reported to the Indiana Department of Education. Acceptance does not determine a student’s eligibility or award amount.

Admissions

Updated 7mo ago

St. Matthew Catholic School (Indianapolis) directs families to apply via its online enrollment application for the 2026–27 school year (create an account, complete the application, submit, and pay the application fee), and to contact the school to schedule a tour. (saintmatt.org) After applying, the school’s published process for new students includes a records review (requesting the prior three years of records such as attendance/discipline/report cards, plus IEP/ISP if applicable and test scores), a parent tour, a student shadow day, a teacher recommendation, and a final family meeting; accepted students then pay a non-refundable $100 registration fee per student. (files.constantcontact.com) Key dates/eligibility noted: for 2026–27, Preschool requires age 3 by August 1, 2026; Pre-K requires age 4 by August 1, 2026; and Kindergarten requires age 5 by August 1, 2026, and the school notes that open enrollment for new non-parishioner families will be reviewed after January 31. (saintmatt.org) Required documents listed for admissions include a birth certificate, immunization records, and a baptismal certificate if applicable; the preschool flyer also notes that 3-year-old preschool students must be potty trained by the start of school. (files.constantcontact.com) The materials reviewed do not describe a waitlist policy or detailed priority categories beyond the note about non-parishioner applications being reviewed after January 31; for tuition purposes, the school distinguishes “active parish family” vs. non-parishioner/inactive parishioner status, and families seeking additional tuition assistance beyond vouchers are asked to complete FACTS Grant & Aid by May 15, 2026. (files.constantcontact.com)

Admissions Timeline

Updated 7mo ago

Interview: Required
Private school survey

PSS ID 00421743

Community
City, Large
Religious orientation
Roman Catholic
School type
Catholic, parochial
Student body
Coed
Enrollment
320 students
Teachers (FTE)
26.3
Student–teacher ratio
12.2:1
Daily instruction
7.2 hours

Student demographics

Hispanic/Latino9.4%
x
White68.4%
x
Black or African American11.6%
x
Asian0.6%
x
Two or More Races9.1%
x
American Indian or Alaska Native0.6%
x
Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander0.3%
x

Sources